We start The Chosen with the pilot, which was released on Christmas Eve in 2017—which is crazy to think nearly nine years have already passed. This pilot is titled, “The Shepherd” and is based on Luke chapter 2.
We see a lame shepherd named Simon struggling to travel. He is travelling on one working leg and is using a makeshift crutch to keep his balance.
His fellow shepherds are frustrated by how much he is slowing them down, and they don’t treat him very well. With his bandaged foot, dirty body, and dirty clothes, even a woman drawing water at the community well did not want to be near him.
They all eventually make their way to the Bethlehem market where the shepherds are trying to sell their unblemished lambs. There is a Pharisee who inspects each lamb first.
While Simon is having his lamb inspected, he shares with the teacher that he has studied the Torah every day and asks the Pharisee when the Messiah will return to redeem the Hebrew people from Roman occupation.
But before he could get a full answer, that same Pharisee became angry as he found a wound on Simon’s lamb. He scolded Simon for not bringing a spotless lamb, which led to one of the shepherds scolding him as well.
To make matters worse, his blemished lamb somehow caused him to fall and scrape his arm.
Despite this recent injury, instead of trying to keep up with the shepherds, Simon sees a synagogue and decides to enter it just to hear a few prophecies being read by a priest.
His time there didn’t last long though, as his scraped arm was starting to drip blood on the ground. Someone noticed that and told Simon to leave, as he was considered filthy and unclean to be in this synagogue.
So not only did Simon have a lamb that was considered unclean, he too was considered unclean.
This is where things get interesting…Because Simon stayed back long enough, he somehow crossed paths with Mary and Joseph.
Joseph asked Simon for directions to the community well, as Mary had gone without drinking any water for hours. Simon gives directions, but kindly offers some of the water he got earlier in the day. This small, kind act was greatly appreciated by Joseph.
They have a brief interaction where Joseph says they travelled from Nazareth. Simon tells him not to say that too loudly as he quotes, “Nothing good can come from Nazareth,” which Joseph is already well aware of.
Simon reassures Joseph that he won’t tell anyone where they came from and their secret is safe with him. Joseph and Mary share a brief smile as if to say, “Oh, there is a secret—you just don’t know about it yet.”
There is a cutaway scene where a priest reads from Isaiah 35, and when he reads verses 3–6, it says:
“Strengthen the feeble hands, steady the knees that give way; say to those with fearful hearts, ‘Be strong, do not fear; your God will come, he will come with vengeance; with divine retribution he will come to save you.’ Then will the eyes of the blind be opened and the ears of the deaf unstopped. Then will the lame leap like a deer.”
I couldn’t help but think that the passage may have been foreshadowing where somehow this lowly shepherd would be healed of his lame body and feeble knees.
Not long after the shepherds set up camp, they are blasted with this powerful, radiant light so strong they can’t even look at it. They hear an angel announce that the Lamb of God is being born.
In their jubilation, they all rush to see the birth of Jesus. What is interesting is that perhaps that foreshadowing came true, because somehow, Simon had the strength in his legs and knees to run—so much strength that he eventually dropped his crutch.
Was he healed based on that scripture of how the lame will leap like a deer? Or did he have such a strong passion to see Jesus that the pain did not matter? It’s odd he would purposefully drop his crutch if he was not healed. I mean, he somehow arrived outside the stable just before the other Shepherds did. And they blow right past Simon to rush into the stable.
The moment I loved most in this episode is when the shepherds greet Joseph and Mary in that stable.
The first one to enter was the old bald shepherd. Mary and Joseph were originally surprised by the unexpected visit. The others then followed, and Simon was the last to come inside the stable.
The shepherds, in awe and reverence, dropped to their knees. They wanted to hold Jesus first, and in fact, that same old bald shepherd—who, in my opinion, treated Simon terribly—was the one who actually reached out his arms first.
But the moment Joseph recognized Simon, he remembered what Simon did for him and his wife earlier. So Joseph instead turned to Simon and passed Jesus over to him. Simon got to hold Jesus first.
I loved this moment. And I loved that the other shepherds who mistreated Simon got to see him have this honour.
This is a moment showing how God sees and rewards those who love a stranger. Simon’s one small, kind act of giving some of his water to Mary led to an unforgettable moment in his life.
Simon’s kind gesture reminded me of verses such as Hebrews 13:2 which says:
“Do not forget to show hospitality to strangers, for by so doing some people have shown hospitality to angels without knowing it.”
and Matthew 25:40:
“The King will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.’
After Simon returns Jesus to Joseph, Mary notices Simon’s bleeding arm and gets Joseph to bandage it. This was another act of kindness Simon received in return.
The final scene is also brilliant, as just when Simon leaves, he is confronted by that same Pharisee from earlier, who asks, “Have you found a spotless lamb for sacrifice?”. Simon’s smile says it all as if to say “Oh I did alright”.
Simon’s smile says it all. For this to be only a 21-minute pilot episode, it shows you what kind of brilliant writing and acting we are in for.